• Add description, images, menus and links to your mega menu

  • A column with no settings can be used as a spacer

  • Link to your collections, sales and even external links

  • Add up to five columns

  • For guaranteed live arrival, choose next day shipping when ordering mantids, order may be canceled. DELAYS from WEATHER ALERT Need help? Contact CLICK Wholesale inquiries

    ~~Heat advisory!~~ Shipping Delays~~

    0

    Your Cart is Empty

    Do insects have feelings? Love or Hate? What’s your opinion

    September 09, 2024 3 min read

    The entomology literature has historically suggested insects cannot feel pain, leading to their exclusion from ethical debates and animal welfare legislation. However, there may be more neural and cognitive/behavioural evidence for pain in insects than previously considered. We use Birch et al. 's (2021) eight criteria for sentience to critically evaluate the evidence for pain in insects. We assess six orders (Blattodea, Coleoptera, Diptera, Hymenoptera, Lepidoptera, and Orthoptera) in at least two life stages (adult and first instarjuveniles, as well as other instars where relevant data are found). Other insect orders have not received enough research effort to be evaluated. According to the Birch et al. framework, adult Diptera (flies and mosquitoes) and Blattodea (cockroaches and termites) satisfy six criteria, constituting strong evidence for pain. Adults of the remaining orders (except Coleoptera, beetles) and some juveniles (Blattodea and Diptera, as well as last instar Lepidoptera [butterflies and moths]) satisfy 3–4 criteria, or “substantial evidence for pain”. We found no good evidence that any insects failed a criterion. However, there were significant evidence gaps, particularly for juveniles, highlighting the importance of more research on insect pain. We conclude by considering the ethical implications of our findings where insects are managed in wild, farmed, and research contexts.

    How we evaluate evidence for pain

    In a report commissioned by the UK government, Birch et al. (2021) developed a new framework for evaluating evidence of animal sentience, with a focus on pain (later published as Crump et al., 2022). Birch et al. (2021) write that “pain is one example within a broader category of negatively-valenced affective states, a category which also includes states of anxiety, fear, hunger, thirst, coldness, discomfort and boredom” (Birch et al., 2021, p. 12). Building on previous work (e.g., Bateson, 1991

    Criterion 1: Nociception

     

    The animal possesses receptors sensitive to noxious (i.e., potentially or actually harmful, damaging) stimuli (nociceptors)

     

    This criterion specifies the most basic prerequisite for experiencing pain. If fulfilled, the animal has the neurobiological capacity for nociception. Vertebrates detect noxious stimuli through specialised peripheral sensory neurons: nociceptive neurons (Dubin and Patapoutian, 2010), characterised by free nerve endings under the epidermis. 
    join the discussion 

    Summary of evidence for insect pain

    In Section 3, we assessed the evidence for k my each criterion in adults and juveniles of six insect orders. Table 11 summarises our confidence levels for adults, and Table 12 summarises our ratings for first (and last) instar juveniles.

    Birch et al. (2021) suggested an approximate grading scheme for communicating the strength of evidence for sentience (specifically for pain). The five grades were:

    • 1.

      Very strong evidence: High or very high confidence that 7–8 criteria are satisfied. Welfare protection

     

    Ethical considerations for the use or management of insects

    Insects are managed in a variety of contexts that may raise welfare concerns, including the food and feed industry, silk/shellac/dye production, waste management, pest/invasive species management, wildlife conservation, beekeeping, zoos and insectariums, research/education settings, the entertainment industry, in medicine, and as pets. By far, the largest number of insects with welfare impacted by human management will be in wild/agricultural settings, followed by the growing insects as food

    Conclusion

    Using the Birch et al. (2021) framework, we reviewed the evidence for sentience (and specifically pain) in six insect orders across their development. We found “strong evidence” for pain experiences in adults of two orders, Diptera (flies and mosquitoes) and Blattodea (cockroaches and termites). There was also “substantial evidence” in adult Hymenoptera (bees, wasps, ants, and sawflies), Orthoptera (crickets and grasshoppers), and Lepidoptera (butterflies and moths), and “some evidence” in

    Acknowledgements

    We thank Elisabetta Versace, Katrin Vogt, Nikita Komarov and Frederic Libersat for their feedback on the manuscript.

    Conflict of interest

    Meghan Barrett reports a relationship with Rethink Priorities that includes: consulting.

    Funding statement

    This research is part of a project that has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme, Grant Number 851145. M.G. received funding from a Queen Mary University of London PhD Studentship. M.B. is currently funded as an NSF postdoctoral research fellow (2109399).

    I’m 

    Leave a comment

    Comments will be approved before showing up.


    Also in Praying Mantis News! Join the conversation.

    How Praying Mantises Hear: One ear
    How Praying Mantises Hear: One ear

    July 19, 2024 2 min read

    Read More
    Identifying Domestic species
    Identifying Domestic species

    July 19, 2024 2 min read

    Identifying domestic species in the USA
    Read More
    Invasive claims and irresponsible advice
    Invasive claims and irresponsible advice

    April 13, 2024 2 min read

    This article is addressed to those who don’t understand how an ecosystem and environment works. There are deeper factors requiring serious consideration
    Read More
    RuffRuff App RuffRuff App by Tsun